Was the Arkenstone a Silmaril? The viral fan theory explained

Welcome, dear traveler, to a scholarly expedition that will take us deep into the heart of Middle-earth lore. Today we embark on an intriguing journey to explore the viral fan theory that suggests the Arkenstone might be more than just a simple gem – it could be a Silmaril!

The Arkenstone: A Gem of Unknown Origins

As the coveted treasure of the Lonely Mountain, the Arkenstone has long been a subject of fascination among scholars and fans alike. Its origins remain shrouded in mystery, with some theories suggesting it was once part of the glorious Silmarils.

Silmarils: The Luminous Jewels of Arda

For those unfamiliar, the Silmarils were three magnificent gems crafted by Fëanor, the most skilled of the Elven Smiths. They contained the holiest light of the Two Trees of Valinor and held the essence of the Elves’ lost world.

The Fan Theory: A Closer Look

The viral fan theory proposes that Thrain, the dwarf who discovered the Arkenstone, was in fact a descendant of Beren and Lúthien, the heroic couple who retrieved one of the Silmarils. This would explain how the Arkenstone ended up in the hands of the dwarves.

The Evidence: Connecting the Dots

Supporters of this theory point to the Arkenstone’s exceptional beauty, power, and connection to the Lonely Mountain as evidence that it might be a Silmaril. They argue that the gem’s properties align with those described in Tolkien’s writings.

The Response: Tolkien Scholars Weigh In

Tolkien scholars have expressed mixed opinions on this theory, with some finding it compelling while others dismiss it as mere speculation. The lack of definitive evidence in Tolkien’s writings leaves the fate of the Arkenstone as a Silmaril unresolved.

Conclusion: A Matter of Debate

As we conclude our exploration of this intriguing fan theory, it is essential to remember that Middle-earth lore is rife with mysteries and hidden connections. The Arkenstone’s true nature may never be definitively proven, leaving us to ponder the possibilities and engage in lively debate.