Was The Arkenstone Actually A Silmaril? The Definitive Theory
Was the Arkenstone Actually a Silmaril? The Definitive Theory
Introduction
In the vast expanse of Middle-earth, few artifacts hold as much allure and intrigue as the legendary Arkenstone. This gem, prized by the dwarves and hidden within the Lonely Mountain, has been a subject of debate among Tolkien scholars for decades. Could it be possible that this seemingly ordinary jewel hides a far greater, more ancient secret? In this article, we delve into the deepest recesses of Tolkien’s lore to explore the theory that the Arkenstone might have once been one of the fabled Silmarils.
The History of the Arkenstone
First discovered by King Thrain I in 1999 of the Third Age, the Arkenstone shone with an inner light that captured the hearts of the dwarves who would come after. However, its true origins may reach back to the very beginning of Middle-earth’s history.
The Arkenstone as a Silmaril
The theory that the Arkenstone is, in fact, a Silmaril gains strength when we consider Tolkien’s own descriptions. When he refers to the Arkenstone as radiating its own inner light untouchable by shadow, it echoes the language used for the Silmarils alone. Furthermore, the timing fits perfectly with our understanding of the Silmarillion. If one of Faernau’s sacred jewels was cast into the earth during the War of Wrath, might it have found its way to the heart of the Lonely Mountain centuries later?
The Evidence
While the connection between the Arkenstone and the Silmarils remains a theory, it is one supported by a wealth of evidence. From the language used to describe the gem in both The Hobbit and the Silmarillion to the chronology that aligns with the fall of the Silmarils, the pieces of the puzzle begin to fit together.
Conclusion
Whether or not the Arkenstone was once a Silmaril remains an open question, one that may never be definitively answered. Yet, as Tolkien scholars and fans of Middle-earth, we must continue to explore these mysteries, seeking out new insights and understanding in the rich tapestry of Tolkien’s legendarium.
Further Reading
For those eager to delve deeper into this theory, we recommend watching “The History of the Arkenstone – Is it a Silmaril? | Tolkien Explained” and “What Was the Arkenstone Really? The Secret No One Told You – LOTR Lore”.
