Introduction: A Tale of Two Powerful Foes

In the grand tapestry of Middle-earth, two formidable adversaries have left indelible marks on the history of this fantastical world: the Witch-king of Angmar and Smaug the Dragon. But what if these two powerful beings had ever crossed paths? In this article, we delve into a thought-provoking hypothetical scenario that challenges the established lore of J.R.R. Tolkien’s epic masterpiece.

The Moment of Deviation

As the story unfolds in the spring of 2941, Gandalf is traveling to the Shire for a brief respite after not visiting in 20 years. The burden on his mind weighs heavily, primarily with Sauron’s presence in Dolgldur, and secondarily with Smaug, the dragon whose allegiance he fears Sauron may find.

In this scenario, Gandalf and Thorin Oakenshield, by being off by even just a day or two, do not meet near Bri. The impact of this seemingly insignificant event is immeasurable.

The North’s Fate Hangs in the Balance

In the canon story, Gandalf is able to convince Thorin of the futility of open war, as stated in Unfinished Tales. However, with no Gandalf to deter him, Thorin moves forward with his plans for battle.

Sauron’s Shadow Grows Darker

Meanwhile, Sauron continues his relentless march towards Mordor, with the Witch-king of Angmar at his side. The war for Mordor rages on, and Talion holds back the forces of darkness for decades.

Conclusion: A World Divided

In this hypothetical world, the balance of power in Middle-earth shifts drastically. The North is consumed by war, while Sauron’s dominion spreads across Mordor. With Smaug alive, the dragon’s fiery breath could add fuel to the fires of darkness.

It is a bleak vision, one that challenges the heroic narrative of The Lord of the Rings. Yet, it serves as a stark reminder of the power struggles that lie beneath the surface of Middle-earth’s tranquil facade.

Further Reading

• What if Smaug Survived? | Tolkien Theory
• Sauron Creates The Witch King of Angmar Scene 4K ULTRA HD Action