5 Lies Bilbo Baggins Told In The Original Hobbit Book
5 Lies Bilbo Baggins Told in the Original Hobbit Book
Introduction
Welcome, dear reader, to an exploration of Middle-earth lore as we delve into the lies that our beloved hobbit, Bilbo Baggins, told in J.R.R. Tolkien’s original Hobbit book. As a senior Tolkien scholar and film critic, I will guide you through five deceptions, omissions, or embellishments Bilbo made, shedding light on the intricacies of Middle-earth and the production history of the films.
The Controversial Addition: Tariel and Keely’s Love Story
One of the most contentious additions to Peter Jackson’s The Hobbit trilogy was the romantic subplot between the Alph dwarf, Tariel, and the dwarf, Keely. In the films, Tariel is a Sylvan Alph who didn’t exist in the book, and her forbidden love with Keely contradicts Tolkien’s established lore.
Azog the Defiler: A Misleading Enemy
If you’ve only watched the movies, you might think Azog the Defiler was one of Thorin’s greatest enemies. On screen, Azog is a hulking orc chieftain who killed Thorin’s grandfather Thror. However, in Tolkien’s writings, Azog did not hold such a significant role in Thorin’s life.
The Altercation with Thorin: A Misunderstood Moment
In one of the most dramatic scenes in The Battle of Five Armies, we see Bilbo and Thorin engaging in a heated argument. However, this scene was heavily influenced by Jackson’s creative liberties, as it does not align with Tolkien’s original story.
The Orc and Stone: A Deception or Reality?
Another deviation from the book is the inclusion of the “Orc and Stone” plot, which plays a significant role in Thorin’s character development. The authenticity of this storyline remains debatable among fans.
Bilbo’s Loyalty: A Questionable Allegiance
Throughout the films, we see Bilbo questioning his loyalty to Thorin and even considering leaving the company. However, in the book, Bilbo’s character remains steadfastly loyal to his dwarf companions.
Conclusion
In this exploration, we have uncovered five instances where Bilbo Baggins strayed from the truth as told in Tolkien’s original Hobbit book. As a senior scholar and film critic, I invite you to continue delving into Middle-earth lore, seeking the truth behind these lies and the many other mysteries that await us.
